Supervision of Spiritual Directors - Spiritual Directors International

Supervision of Spiritual Directors: Engaging in Holy Mystery by Mary Rose Bumpus and Rebecca Bradburn Langer

Reviews for Supervision of Spiritual Directors: Engaging in Holy Mystery

"This volume, edited by Mary Rose Bumpus and Rebecca Bradburn Langer, is a welcome addition to the relatively limited literature on the supervision of spiritual directors. The book is divided into three sections.

The three essays in Part I deal with the question, “What is Supervision?” These essays are helpful in exploring what is unique to supervision of spiritual directors (as opposed, for example, to supervision of therapists). While the authors take different approaches, they tend to focus on what might broadly be termed the “contemplative” aspects of supervision. What is the vocation and charism of the person receiving supervision? How might God be working in the lives of those with whom the spiritual director is meeting?

Part II is entitled “Specific Topics in Supervision” and contains four essays dealing with support of beginning directors, listening to the various dimensions of human experience (sensations, emotions, and thoughts), appropriate attention to sexuality, and avoiding ethical quagmires. If Part I lays out some theoretical approaches to supervision, Part II contains practical suggestions and helpful case studies. Beginning supervisors will especially find these chapters enlightening, and even experienced supervisors will find insights worth further mining. This reviewer found the essays on sexuality and on ethical quagmires particularly helpful.

Finally, the three essays in Part III explore the topic of “Worldview and Supervision.” The authors in this section argue that the context of supervision goes well beyond the one-to-one encounter taking place in the supervisor’s office. The essays explore issues embedded in social or institutional structures, in “co-cultures” (or what readers may more familiarly call sub-cultures), and in the disabled community. The first essay lays out a helpful model of discussing supervision in dimensions of human experience which are nonthematic (diffuse and inarticulate), imagistic (affective-imaginative), and interpretive (logical, propositional).

A particularly useful appendix in the book presents a Contemplative Reflection Form which can be adapted by other supervisors after receiving written permission. This is a form which supervisees fill in prior to meeting with their supervisor. This tool is worth considering for adaptation to other programs.

The authors in this volume are almost all associated with the Diploma in Spiritual Direction offered by San Francisco Theological Seminary in San Anselmo, CA. The advantage of this is that they share a similar approach to supervision; the disadvantage is that a wider variety of voices is not heard. Also, several of the articles, in this reviewer’s opinion, addressed spiritual direction almost as much as they addressed supervision. A clearer distinction of supervision from spiritual direction would be appreciated.

Overall, Supervision of Spiritual Directors is well done and a must read for those involved in this ministry. Supervisors will find helpful suggestions both for the theory and the practice of supervision." —Bruce H. Lescher, Ph.D., Jesuit School of Theology at Berkeley. The review first appeared in "Reflective Practice: Formation and Supervision in Ministry," vol 27

“Supervision of Spiritual Directors: Engaging in Holy Mystery makes a fine contribution to the training of spiritual directors. I highly recommend it as an excellent resource for new and experienced supervisors and spiritual directors.” —Cissy McLane, co-founder of the Ignation Spirituality Center, Seattle, Washington, USA.

Supervision of Spiritual Directors: Engaging in Holy Mystery.
Mary Rose Bumpus and Rebecca Bradburn Langer, ed., (Harrisburg: Morehouse, 2005)

An introduction explaining the historical reasons for the growing interest in supervision alerts us to the “much more out there” than what might have become a routine approach to this important discipline. The book looks at three major areas: “What is Supervision?”, “Specific Topics in Supervision,” and “Worldview and Supervision.”

Part One offers three different views of what supervision can be. The first chapter, assistance of an absent other (the directee), is refreshing as it invites the supervisor to be flexible in focus, keeping the well-being of the directee as the primary concern. This is worth reading if you have been frustrated these past fifty years by focusing on “what is going on in the director?” A contemplative approach to the relationship (between supervisor and director) focuses on the “deep spiritual identity of the director, who he or she is in God, rather than correct or incorrect performance at the behavioral level.” It calls for the development of charisms in director and supervisor, and finishes with a quote from Rumi that sees supervision as “a guest house,” an image that encourages us to welcome all who enter there. Chapter three presents a set of goals or tasks toward which the supervisor will want to move, distinguishes supervision from consultation, and includes “what supervision is not.” It ends with a thoughtful note about those one should serve with caution or not at all. This first part of the book is substantial and helpful.

Looking ahead, Part Two considers specific topics such as supporting beginning directors, dimensions of the human person in relationship, sexuality and God’s eros, and avoiding common quagmires (looks helpful!). Part Three encourages broadened ways of seeing things, considers co-cultures and explores direction of disabled persons. This book has been well edited, pulling together the thoughts of supervisors who have extended experience and who seem to be connected to one another in what must be a small world of practitioners. There is much to digest here. I intend to take my time and savor every bite of it.

Across the top of the front cover we see “A Spiritual Directors International Book.” The Spiritual Directors International imprint means that the organization has reviewed this text in collaboration with Morehouse, and wants to point it out as an especially worthwhile book for spiritual directors. Indeed it is!

Janet Blakeley